Thursday 18 June 2020

Our souls, our spirits, our hearts. They are not the same.


I was asked recently to give some Bible teaching to deal with the double lives that plague some Christians. Hands raised in the air in worship at church; hands on the keyboard at home to look at a porn site. Tongues full of praise for God in church; tongues full of curses at home. It’s an old but sad story.

I thought the best approach would be to give some teaching about the heart, for when things are well in the heart, usually the journey is gentler. So I had to define my terms. When the Bible talks about our hearts (which it does over 700 times) does it just mean all our inner life? Does that mean our souls, our spirits, and our hearts are all the same or are they different?

These are important questions. So I reached for my copy of Walther Eichrodt’s ‘Theology of the Old Testament’, a sure guide if ever there was one, and got to work. I also looked at some Tom Wright, always good value. And the faithful IVP’s New Bible Dictionary.

Here – very briefly – are my conclusions:

The Soul

The Hebrew word for soul is nephesh, and it literally means the throat, the place our breath passes through. The famous Leviticus 17:11 underlines the same point. It says: ‘The life of the flesh is in the blood’, the word for life here is nephesh. Interestingly Eichrodt tells us that the root word for blood in Arabic is nafs, and that has come into Persian where nafs can mean both breath and soul. So the word soul simply means our life. When our breath stops, so our soul dies. Later the word came to be a way of referring to our whole selves, so David’s ‘Bless the Lord, O my soul’. Both Eichrodt and Tom Wright robustly reject the idea that there is an invisible soul in each person that goes on living. Wright says there is not a hint of this in the Bible. This rejection of an invisible eternal soul is confirmed by the resurrection. Jesus was raised from the dead not as a soul or a spirt, but as a physical man. And with the eating of the piece of fish He went out of his way to prove this.

The Spirit

The Hebrew word for spirit is ruah and it literally means wind. There are two aspects to our spirits. One is that this is the deepest part of our being where our most powerful and profound senses lie. The other is that this is the part of our being that makes contact with outside spirits, or responds to outside events that have an overwhelming impact on us. When someone turns to God, it is this part of our being that meets the Holy Spirit. One writer put it like this:

Man’s spirit is his inward organ for him to contact God, receive God, contain God, and assimilate God into His entire being as his life and his everything.

The Heart

In the Bible the heart is the seat of government in a person’s life. It is the control centre. In the heart is our will, our thinking, our conscience, our feelings, which are all expressed through our body. So the body and the heart are wholly woven together. While today we associate thinking with the head, in the Old Testament it was seen to happen in the heart. Jesus had the same view, so he asks the frowning Pharisees why they are questioning – in their hearts.

The main difference: control and responsibility

My existence is not in my hand. I do not control when I was born, or when I will die. This is not my arena of responsibility.

Likewise we are not in control over the spirit world, certainly not of God’s spirit. Jesus underlines this in his famous conversation with Nicodemus – ‘the wind blows where it wills.’

When it comes to our hearts it is different. We have control. Our wills can choose to move towards God, and so connect with His Spirit; or to move away. We can think things through carefully. We can listen to the witness of our conscience. We can be sensitive to our feelings and bodies and govern our lives in a way which is best for them.

So, when it comes to moving away from the double life, it makes sense to get Christians to look carefully at their hearts, and to think through how they can work with the Holy Spirit for its renovation.

If this is of any interest to you probably the greatest modern writer on this subject is Dallas Willard. Anything by Willard is worth reading, but especially his, ‘Renovation of the Heart.’


No comments:

Post a Comment

Followers